Classic Pizza Joints in Bemidji

🍕 Classic Local Pizza Joints (Worth a Visit)

🍕 Dave's Pizza

A beloved family pizza place that’s been drawing crowds since the ’50s. Known for doing both classic and creative pies — from extra‑cheesy classics to deep dish — Dave’s has that hometown feel and longstanding local reputation. Great for casual dine‑in or take‑home comfort food.

🍕 Keith's Pizza - North (and South location Keith's Pizza‑South)

A local staple for decades, Keith’s hand‑tossed pizzas use fresh, handmade dough and toppings. With two locations, you can grab a classic pepperoni or specialty pizza, plus subs, pastas, and salads. Locals praise the cozy, family‑friendly vibe and consistent quality.

🍕 Giovanni's Pizza

Famous for its pizza buffet, Giovanni’s mixes simple comfort with hearty portions, offering pizza along with a salad bar and pastas. It’s a go‑to for family nights or group gatherings — casual, classic, and always ready to satisfy a big appetite.

🍕 Jake’s Pizza

Slightly off the main Bemidji strip, Jake’s is worth the short drive for its simply excellent pizza made to order. With hearty reviews and a thoughtful menu, this is one of the best hidden gems if you’re craving a slightly different pizza experience outside downtown.

🍕 National & Chain Options

🍕 Green Mill Restaurant & Bar

A hybrid bar‑and‑grill that’s well‑known in the Upper Midwest, Green Mill brings deep‑dish and classic pizzas alongside a full menu (burgers, pastas, wings). It’s a great option if you want pizza with craft beer, sports on the TV, or a casual dinner with friends/family.

🍕 Pizza Hut

The classic pizza chain option in Bemidji — perfect if you’re craving pan, hand‑tossed, or stuffed crust at a budget‑friendly price. Add wings and sides to round out your meal. Good for delivery or take‑out 🍕.

🍕 Papa Murphy's

Not cooked in‑store, but great for take‑and‑bake pizza if you want fresh pizza at home. You pick your toppings and bake it at just the right moment — ideal for movie nights or hosting guests.

🍕 Domino's Pizza & 🍕 Little Caesars

Iconic pizza chains offering fast, dependable pies — from Domino’s build‑your‑own to Little Caesars’ Hot‑N‑Ready classics. Perfect for quick grabs or feeding a crowd on a budget.

🍕 Pizza with a Twist – Non‑Traditional Places with Pizza

🍕 Pizza Ranch

A pizza buffet and fried chicken spot just north of downtown — casual and kid‑friendly, with plenty of variety for mixed groups.

🍕 Bemidji Bowl

Bowling and pizza combine at this fun stop — classic slices while you bowl a few frames or hang out with friends (plus arcade games for good measure).

🍕 BoardWalk

Great for summer vibes — this lakeside minigolf and snack spot has wood‑fire pizza alongside ice cream and snacks, perfect for a casual day out with views.

🍕 The Other Place

A neighborhood bar serving up bar‑made pizza with local toppings. Casual and lively, it’s great for a late‑night slice with drinks or friends.

🍕 Bonus: Places With Pizza Appearing on the Menu

While not pizza joints per se, certain bars and grills like Bar 209 and Lazy Jack's offer pizza or pizza‑style flatbreads among other menu items — good for when you want variety with your slice.

🍽️ Tips for Your Pizza Tour

• Classic local flavor: Start at Dave’s or Keith’s for pizza that feels like Bemidji.

• Buffet night: Giovanni’s and Pizza Ranch bring all‑you‑can‑eat vibes.

• Casual + drinks: Green Mill, BoardWalk, or The Other Place are perfect for relaxed pizza outings.

• Chains on speed dial: Pizza Hut, Domino’s, Papa Murphy’s, and Little Caesars cover the basics — especially good for quick delivery or take‑home pizza nights.